The first question on most renovation plans is whether a particular wall can come out. The answer turns on one distinction: whether the wall carries load. This guide explains how that distinction works in an HDB flat, how to establish it reliably, and what the rules permit in each case.
The basic distinction
A structural wall carries load from the floors above and transfers it down through the building. Removing one, or cutting into one, affects the structure of the whole block rather than just your flat. In HDB flats these are reinforced concrete walls, and they cannot be hacked under any circumstances. No permit covers it.
A non-structural wall divides space without carrying load. These are typically lightweight partitions or non-load-bearing blockwork. They can usually be removed or opened up, with a renovation permit.
Everything else follows from that. The practical difficulty is not understanding the distinction, it is establishing which one you are looking at.
How to tell reliably
The reliable method is the flat's structural plan. It marks reinforced concrete walls explicitly, and HDB can provide the plan for your flat. A registered renovation contractor will read it before quoting, and any contractor who offers to remove a wall without looking at the plan is guessing.
The unreliable methods, in rough order of how often they mislead people:
- Tapping for a hollow sound. A hollow response suggests a lightweight partition, but plenty of non-structural blockwork sounds solid, and finishes change the sound. This has led to expensive mistakes.
- Judging by thickness. Structural walls are often thicker, but not always, and applied finishes disguise the underlying thickness.
- Comparing with a neighbour. Different blocks use different structural arrangements. A wall that came out of a flat down the road tells you nothing about yours.
- Assuming by age. Older flats generally have more non-structural partitions, but this is a tendency, not a rule you can rely on for a specific wall.
Each of these is treated as evidence far more often than it deserves. The plan settles it; nothing else does.
What can never be hacked
Regardless of what you want to achieve, these are fixed:
Reinforced concrete walls
Load-bearing by design. Not removable, not open-able, and not available for chasing services into.
Beams, columns and floor slabs
The same principle. Cutting into a beam to gain ceiling height, or into a slab to sink a service run, is not permitted.
The household shelter
Every flat built since the late 1990s has one. Its walls, floor, ceiling and door are all protected. You cannot hack it, drill into it, remove its door, or fix anything to its surfaces.
This restriction surprises people most, because the shelter usually looks like an ordinary store room and is often in an inconvenient place. It is a civil defence structure with a specific performance requirement, and the restriction covers even mounting a shelf. If your layout plan involves the shelter, the plan needs to change.
Anything shared with a neighbour
Party walls and shared structures are common property. They are not yours to alter, whatever the arrangement with the neighbour.
What can usually be hacked
With a permit, and subject to the structural plan confirming the wall is non-structural:
- Non-load-bearing partitions between rooms
- Bedroom partitions, where the flat layout allows removal
- Wall and floor tiles, along with the bedding beneath them
- Non-structural sections to form a doorway or pass-through
Two qualifications matter. First, permission is required even where the wall is clearly non-structural, so "can be hacked" is not the same as "can be hacked without asking." Second, forming an opening is not always simpler than full removal, since the opening may need a lintel above it, which has to be shown in the application.
The open kitchen question
Opening a kitchen to the living area is one of the most requested changes, and one of the most frequently misunderstood.
Whether it is possible depends on the wall between the two spaces. Where that wall is non-structural, an opening can generally be formed with approval. Where it is reinforced concrete, it cannot, and no amount of design work changes that.
There is a separate consideration beyond the structure. Kitchens in HDB flats have fire safety requirements relating to separation from the rest of the flat, and an open kitchen arrangement may be subject to conditions. This is worth establishing at the design stage rather than after the joinery has been ordered.
Floor tiles and screed
Removing floor finishes is hacking work and needs a permit. Two constraints apply beyond the permit itself.
There are limits on screed removal. The screed contributes to the floor build-up and, in wet areas, sits above the waterproofing membrane. Removing more than permitted affects both loading and waterproofing.
The waterproofing membrane is below the screed in wet areas. In bathrooms and service yards, hacking through to the slab breaches the membrane. Once breached it must be reinstated before new finishes go down, or water finds its way into the unit below. This is the single most common cause of disputes between neighbours after a renovation, and it is entirely preventable by working to the tile bed rather than through it.
Bathrooms specifically
Bathroom hacking carries the highest risk of expensive consequences, for the waterproofing reason above. Wall tiles, floor tiles, sanitary ware and partitions can generally be removed with a permit, but the work needs care about what sits beneath.
If the membrane is disturbed, it has to be redone and tested before re-tiling. A contractor who removes bathroom tiles and says nothing about the membrane has either checked it or has not thought about it, and it is worth knowing which.
Before you commit to a layout
The order that avoids wasted design work:
- Obtain the structural plan for your flat
- Mark which walls are reinforced concrete and treat them as fixed
- Locate the household shelter and treat it as fixed
- Design the layout around what is left
- Have a registered contractor confirm the proposal before anything is ordered
- Apply for the permit, allowing time for any PE endorsement
Designing first and checking later is the more common sequence, and it is how people end up paying for drawings of a layout that was never going to be approved.
support_agent Get a firm price for your job
Any figures on this page are indicative market ranges, not a quote. We survey the site, confirm what needs approval, prepare the permit submission where one is required, and quote in writing.
request_quote Request a quote